As we head into the final week of this year's Semifinal round, I thought it might be interesting to take a look back at what I see as the Top 10 Semifinal performances through the years.
A couple of notes on this list:
- This year's performances are not included
- Starting in Season 4, the format changed from voting contestants into the Top 12 to eliminating the lowest polling contestants from the competition, so Season 4 and 5 contestants had 3 Semifinal performance, versus just 1 for contestants from Seasons 1-3.
And, the list...
10. Katharine McPhee, "Since I Fell For You" (Season 5)
Although she was dressed rather plainly in jeans and a top for her first Semifinal appearance, the effortless way Katharine handled the runs on this Barbra Streisand tune made it clear she was gonna be a contender.
9. EJ Day, "I'll Be" (Season 1)
A replacement for a contestant kicked off the show (the very first of many!), EJ shocked (shocked!) both the viewers and judges with an octave-scaling performance of the Edwin McCain hit. Even Simon had to acknowledge the stunning vocal work EJ displayed. He would only last one more week in the competition, but this performance is not a bad legacy.
8. Jennifer Hudson, "Imagine" (Season 3)
Clad all in white, Jennifer stared down the camera with her wild eyes as she belted the heck out of the John Lennon classic. While the viewers did not vote her through (she squeezed her way into the Top 12 as a wildcard), this performance alerted viewers that this girl could siiiiiiing. Although, having said that, I can't imagine a single viewer thought to themself, "In a few years this time this girl is gonna be an Oscar winner." Funny how American Idol life works!
7. Bo Bice, "Whipping Post" (Season 4)
Until Bo Bice picked up that mike stand and went to town on the Allman Brothers Band tune, the closest thing AI had to a rocker was Justin Guarini (and that ain't too close). With this performance Bice, who had received very little screen time coming into the semifinals in favor of fellow "rocker" Constantine Maroulis, established himself as a showman, a vocal talent, and the "credible rocker" of Season 4.
6. Kimberley Locke, "Somewhere Over The Rainbow" (Season 2)
Sure, she sang this song in her initial audition, and by the time she reprised the performance in the second week of semifinals (which also featured Ruben Studdard and Clay Aiken) there was already some "Rainbow" fatigue, but her controlled and beautiful rendition of the Judy Garland chestnut made clear Season 2 wasn't just going to be a boy's race to the finish.
5. Fantasia, "Something to Talk About" (Season 3)
That voice. Those lips. That sassy personality. Ms. 'Tasia announced her presence to the world as the final performer of week 1's semifinals in Season 3, and never looked back. Flawless.
4. Clay Aiken, "Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me" (Season 2)
His initial audition was shocking for the discrepancy between the way he looked and sounded, and his semifinal performance of the Journey classic "Open Arms" was great, but it was his stunning Wildcard rendition of the Elton John tune that really put Clay Aiken on the map. Standing tall in the center of the stage, looking confident but not cocky, he saaaaaaaaang his way into the hearts of millions. This was the moment, I believe, that Clay Nation really began to take shape.
3. Chris Daughtry, "Hemmorage" (Season 5)
If Bo Bice started the rock trend on American Idol, Chris Daughtry hammered it home. After a solid cover of Bon Jovi's "Wanted Dead or Alive" in the first week of the semifinals, Daughtry stepped it up about 8 notches on this Fuel song, transporting himself and the viewers to the middle of a slammin' rock concert. Bo Bice may have been credible within the world of AI, but Daughtry took it to another level. Its no wonder he's had such a successful post-show transition into the rock music world.
2. Kelly Clarkson, "Respect" (Season 1)
I know, I know, how could I not put Ms. Kelly at number 1, especially when this was the very first the audience was seeing of the sassy Texan? Her vocal work and irrepressible personality were astoundingly clear as she wailed the Aretha classic, all the while missing which camera she was supposed to be looking into. (If you can get your hands on this performance, it really is a must watch, as Kelly adorably, and consistently, is looking anywhere but where the camera is). Coming into this week, Justin was the one to watch. At the end of the week, it was Kelly people were talking about.
1. Latoya London, "All By Myself" (Season 3)
I can still remember the moment when I literally fell off my bed as Latoya hit the impossibly high note in Eric Carmen's ballad....Anymooooooooooooooooooooore. Jaw. On. Floor. Aside from Kelly Clarkson's first performance in the Top 10, this may be the most surprising performance I have ever seen on the show, made all the more so because we had not seen Latoya onscreen for even one minute leading up to the semifinals. Her personality ultimately ended up disappointing me later in the competition, but her vocal work in her first performance is truly unforgettable.
Thoughts? Agree? Disagree? Did I miss something? Let me know.
Posts
8 comments:
I find it interesting that so many people have such different lists. I dislike Kelly Calrkson and wouldn't have put her near the top . I do think that Tamyra and Clay were the top acts of this list. Great blog Thanks.
ok, c'mon you surely cannot completely ignore Taylor Hicks. I mean every judge agreed that his performance of Taking it to the Streets was incredible. The guy won by leaps and bounds. So he is more of a live entertainer...I know it is your choice and opinion,,,but wow, even Taylor critics generally agre that was a great performance.
If I was including an Honorable Mention addendum to the list, Taylor would definitely be on it, along with Tamyra Gray's "And I Am Telling You," Diana Degarmo's "I Got The Music In Me," and Elliott's "Moody's Mood For Love." But with only 10 spots, Taylor didn't make the cut. Sorry! :(
You forgot about Ace Young's performance of "Father Figure." Although he doesn't have the vocal chops of say, Elliott Yamin, the performance he delivered was DRIPPING with sex appeal. I remember watching it with a guy friend, and when it was over, he actually said, "dude, that made me kind of uncomfortable...like, gay-ish."
Elliott Yamin's If You Realy Love Me.
Also, I don't think we need to forget about Anwar Robinson "What A Wonderful World," Paris Bennett "Midnight Train to Georgia," Tamyra (who was already mentioned), and even some people who didn't make the Top 10/12, Lisa Leuschner "Sweet Thing," and Susan Vulaca "Unbreak My Heart."
Elliott Yamin's "Moody's Mood For Love" and/or "If You Really Love Me." 2 of the best ever
Kelly definitely dserved the #1 spot on this list. She delivered with RESPECT, even moreso than Aretha herself. Kelly showed all of America what she had to offer and her performances only got better from this song on.
Post a Comment