Top 8 Performances: Haley Scarnato

Back in Season 3 Diana Degarmo tore this song apart. Haley -- not so much.

This was the definition of a karaoke performance -- not a lick of originality in the entire 90 seconds. Unless you consider distorting the melody to the point that it becomes unrecognizable as originality. And, well, I don't.

And her look was just not workin' for her tonight. Her makeup was so thick she looked almost clown-esque, and I'm so over the short-shorts. I'm glad Simon called her out on her "strategy" of wearing as few clothes as possible. I mean, honestly, there are thousands of girls in this country with great legs and passable singing voices.

Can we please send this girl home already? Please?

GRADE: C+


1. Blake Lewis
2. Chris Richardson
3. Jordin Sparks
4. Phil
5. LaKisha Jones
6. Melinda Doolittle
7. Sanjaya Malakar
8. Haley