Showing posts with label Brandon Rogers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Brandon Rogers. Show all posts

Thursday, January 10, 2008

One Day Left To Vote in IDOL MADNESS: THE GAME Preliminary Rounds

There's about one day left to vote in the preliminary rounds of IDOL MADNESS: THE GAME.

In the girls race between the 11th and 12th place finishers, Stephanie Edwards is still leading the pack with more than 60% of the vote, and looks to be a shoo-in to make it to the main draw. Melissa McGhee and Mikalah Gordon are battling it out for the second position, with McGhee currently enjoying the slight advantage.

On the boys side, Brandon Rodgers is way out in front with nearly 70% of the vote. Matthew Rogers and Charles Grigsby are neck-and-neck in the second place position, with Kevin Covais not too far behind in fourth.

Vote in the IDOL MADNESS: THE GAME preliminary rounds now!

Wednesday, January 09, 2008

IDOL MADNESS: THE GAME Mid-Week Report

Preliminary voting is underway in IDOL MADNESS: THE GAME!

As of this morning, Stephanie Edwards and Melissa McGhee are leading the pack for the female 11th and 12th place finishers, while Brandon Rodgers and Matthew Rogers are ahead for the 11th and 12th place male finishers.

Visit the IDOL MADNESS: THE GAME main page to cast your vote!

Monday, January 07, 2008

IDOL MADNESS: THE GAME Is Here!

As The Enlightened Bracketologist asks, "What could be simpler than breaking down a choice into either/or, black or white, this one or that one?"

The Contest

Who is the best finalist to ever compete on American Idol? Who is your all-time favorite Idol? More importantly, how could you decide? The answer is finally here in Idol Madness: The Game.

Starting next week, we will bring you 1-on-1 match-ups of all the American Idol finalists from the first 6 seasons of American Idol. In every match-up, you will choose only 1 of the 2 contestants to move on to the next round of the competition until we are left with only 1, the ULTIMATE American Idol!

The Finalists
All of the 70 AI finalists from Seasons 1-6 will be a part of this competition. All 60 of the Top 10 finalists are automatically into the final 64-Idol field. The remaining 10 contestants (Charles Grigsby, Vanessa Olivarez, Matthew Rogers, Leah LaBelle, Mikalah Gordon, Lindsey Cardinale, Kevin Covais, Melissa McGhee, Stephanie Edwards, and Brandon Rogers) will have to face off in a preliminary round to decide which 4 of them should complete the final field.

Once the field is set, we will release the tournament brackets and begin the head-to-head face-offs to the Sweet 16, the Elite Eight, the Final Four, and the Ultimate American Idol! Only your votes decide who moves on!

Preliminary voting starts TODAY!

Vote in Preliminary Round: 11th and 12th Place Male Finishers Play-In

Vote in Preliminary Round: 11th and 12th Place Female Finishers Play-In

Visit IDOL MADNESS: THE GAME Main Page

Post any questions in the comments section below.

Click to visit Idol Thought's AMERICAN IDOL CENTRAL for show recaps and rankings, news on former contestants, best-of lists and much more

**Thanks to the Idol Thoughts reader who has agreed to help out with the game.

Thursday, March 15, 2007

Idol Contestant Profile: Brandon Rogers


Brandon Rogers

Season 6, 12th place

Post AI Album: N/A

Website: http://www.myspace.com/brandonrogers

AI Website: http://www.americanidol.com/contestants/season6/brandon_rogers/

Click to visit Idol Thought's AMERICAN IDOL CENTRAL for show recaps and rankings, news on former contestants, best-of lists and much more

Upcoming Idol TV Appearances

They've already taken over the radio, now they are headed for a TV set near you. In the next 10 days, no fewer than 6 former Idol contestants, including Brandon Rogers, the most recent former Idol contender, will be appearing on talk shows or other television programs. Here's a handy chart so you don't miss your favorite Idol...set your Tivo now!

(Check your local listings for exact times)

Brandon Rogers
Live with Regis and Kelly (ABC) March 19
Ellen Degeneres Show (NBC) March 19

Bucky Covington
Live with Regis and Kelly (ABC) March 21

Carrie Underwood
American Idol Extra (Fox Reality) various times
Saturday Night Live (NBC) March 24 11:30PM

Chris Daughtry
Late Night with Conan O'Brien (NBC) March 21 12:35AM

Elliott Yamin
Live with Regis & Kelly (ABC) March 20

Josh Gracin
Live with Regis & Kelly (ABC) March 22

Bye Bye Brandon: Top 12 Results Show Recap



For weeks now we've been hearing (or screaming about) how the girls this year on American Idol are far better than the boys. Tonight, the voters echoed that sentiment, making Brandon Rogers the first contestant eliminated from this year's Top 12. He was joined by Sanjaya Malakar in the Bottom 2, with Phil Stacey named the third lowest votegetter.

Okay, those are the facts. Now, for my feelings...

ARGHHHHHHHHHHHH! We were soooooooo close to getting rid of Sanjaya. So very, very close. It was like a cruel tease.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not sad to see Brandon go, since he just never made good on the promise he showed in his initial audition. But I would have happily accepted another "backup singer's backup singer" performance from Brandon if it meant we'd seen the last of Sanjaya and his ever-evolving coif. But no. Wasn't meant to be.

It will be interesting to see whether the Sanjaya machine has just simply lost steam and he will make his exit next week, or whether his "fanbase" will rally and save him again. Here's hoping it's the former.

On tonight's show we were also treated to:


  • A recap of last night's much-discussed "is he or isn't he" exchange between Ryan and Simon. Apparently the producers of the show thought it sooooooo funny it needed to be shown again.

  • A group number that clearly illustrated which gender is better represented in this competition. I particularly enjoyed the pairing of LaKisha and Sanjaya. I guess the producers do have a sense of humor after all.

  • A Ford commercial to a Modest Mouse song? Wow, American Idol is so indie rock.

  • A screechy performance from Diana Ross, where she repeated the same refrain of the song easily 12 times in a row. Is that the whale sound Simon was referring to on Tuesday night?

So, for the first time since Season 1 a boy gets sent packin' first. What other surprises does this season have in store?


Click to read Top 12 Performances Recap

Wednesday, March 14, 2007

Who's Going Home?



Even though I'm still reeling from last night's very disappointing performances, it's time to turn my thoughts to who is going to join in the illustrious company of EJ Day, Vanessa Olivarez, Leah Labelle, Lindsay Cardinale, and Melissa McGhee by becoming the first contestant voted out of this year's Finals. With so many contestants and so many rocky performances, I think the best way to make a prediction as to who is going to get kicked off tonight is by process of elimination -- figure out who is most likely to be safe, and go from there. As such, I've identified three zones: Green (safe), Yellow (not on solid ground), and Red (danger danger danger!) Here goes...

Click here to read my Top 12 Performances Recap.

Green Zone: Safe
Lakisha "Kiki" Jones and Melinda Doolittle are about as safe this week as they could possibly be, as both gave great performances that were head and shoulders above the rest of the field, and both have huge fan bases that won't let them down this early in the competition. Jordin Sparks was this week's recipient of the "pimp" spot (the last performance slot) and received raves from the judges, so she should most assuredly live to see another week. I'm also going to add Blake Lewis and Chris Richardson into this category...although neither was at their best last night, I think they have a solid enough group of fans at this point that they shouldn't be too concerned.

Yellow Zone: Not on solid ground
Chris Sligh got hammered by the judges after turning "Endless Love" into Coldplay-lite and Gina Glocksen rocked herself right into the ground on "Lovechild," but I'm guessing both of these contestants earned enough goodwill in the semifinals that they should avoid elimination this week (although I wouldn't be shocked if either of them slipped into the Bottom 3). Phil Stacey did better than he has done the last few weeks, so I imagine he'll pick up enough votes to hang around a bit longer. I'm also, much to my chagrin, going to have to put Sanjaya Malakar in this category...even though he was definitively the worst (which says a lot on a night that featured predominantly bad performances), if John Stevens or Kevin Covais is any indication, he won't be standing anywhere near center stage this evening.

Red Zone: Danger! Danger! Danger!
Brandon Rogers. Stephanie Edwards. Haley Scarnato. Each was on slightly shaky grounds coming into the Finals. All three forgot their words. None gave inspiring performances. Therefore, I'm guessing Brandon, Stephanie, and Haley will make up this week's Bottom 3.

Here's where it gets really difficult...which one is going to go?

I went to sleep last night thinking Stephanie was a goner...my thought process was that even though Brandon and Haley forgot their words, they did so in such an obvious way that it might actually earn them a few sympathy votes (especially Haley, who turned into a total mess as she listened to the judges' comments and then thanked them profusely for finally saying something even remotely kind).

Then I started thinking it was Brandon who was going to go...that one-spot (first performance slot) has killed much better singers than Brandon.

But when it comes down to it, I'm gonna have to go with Haley as the first eliminated contestant this season. She just doesn't have the goods to compete with the other girls, and despite McPheever-ing herself out last night, I think she's out of her depth in this competition.

So there it is...Haley's gonna go.

Gulp.

Stop! In The Name of My Ears: Top 12 Performance Recap


Coming into tonight, I was excited. I mean, this is the beginning of the phase of the competition true-blue Idol-holics like myself fiend for...the countdown to number one. I was ready to be blown away.

I gotta say...I was thoroughly underwhelmed.

(My list of best-to-worst appears at the bottom. You can click on any contestant's name to get more detailed comments on their performance.)

Before I get to the performances, a few notes on the show:

- Did anyone else notice that winners Ruben and Taylor were conspicuously missing from the "Idol success" montage at the beginning of the show?
- Paula cried during the second performance of the finals. That's gotta be some sort of record.
-How about that homoerotic exchange between Simon and Ryan? Boys, boys, save it for the bedroom.
-Diana Ross invented a new musical expression..."you've got to pronunciate the words." Um, I think she meant enunciate. And then Paula actually used the word enunciate in her comments. Genius.
-They've gotta be better next week, right? Right?

So, yes, there was a standout performance (the sensational LaKisha Jones, who was every bit as good if not better singing "God Bless The Child" than she was during her first semfinal performance) and a strong second best (Melinda Doolittle, who I thought was solid as always on "Home", but not as vocally dynamic as I would have hoped). It's moving beyond the clear top two that it starts to get a little dicey.

Jordin Sparks did fine with "If We Hold on Together", I thought, but was overpraised by the judges, while Phil Stacey improved upon his last couple of performances with a well-sung but still far short of spectacular version of "I'm Going To Make You Love Me." Chris Richardson became the first AI6 finalist to stampede into the audience to get to the middle platform (I hate it when they do that!), and he wandered all around the pitch, but was adorable as always, so I wanna cut him a little bit of slack. Gina Glocksen, as promised, brought back her "edge," but she lost her sense of fun in the process and was entirely uninspiring and forgettable singing "Lovechild."

Stephanie Edwards forgot her words singing "Love Hangover," but at least she covered, which is more than can be said for Brandon Rogers("Can't Hurry Love") and Haley Scarnato ("Missing You"). Shockingly I'm giving my most improved award this week to Sanjaya Malakar. Mind you, I still think he was abominally, embarrassingly terrible, but ever-so slightly less so than the last three weeks. So, Sanjaya, kudos for that.

Which brings us to Blake Lewis("Set Me Free") and Chris Sligh("Endless Love"), both of whom re-arranged their songs to the displeasure of the judges. Now mind you, I didn't particularly care for Chris' performance, and I did think Blake could have shown off his voice to better effect, but I don't like that the judges are dissuading the contestants from being musically adventurous. Yes, a classic is a classic, but if the success of Kelly, Carrie and Chris has taught us anything, its that in order to be successful once you've appeared on Idol you have to show that you can be musically relevant in today's marketplace. When forced to sing inane themes like "the Diana Ross songbook," they have to figure out a way to infuse their own flavor into the performance, and I admire Blake and Chris for trying something that hasn't been done before.

So, who's gonna go? I need a bit more time to think on it. Because there are so many contestants there is a lot of potential for a surprise result due to vote-splitting, but I'd be shocked if it wasn't Brandon, Haley, or Stephanie (of course I'd like to see Sanjaya given the boot, but chances of that happening first week out are pretty slim). Guess we'll have to wait and see...

My Rankings, from best to worst: (Click on a contestant's name to read more detailed comments on their performance)
1. Lakisha Jones
2. Melinda Doolittle
3. Blake Lewis
4. Jordin Sparks
5. Chris Richardson
6. Phil Stacey
7. Chris Sligh
8. Stephanie Edwards
9. Gina Glocksen
10. Haley Scarnato
11. Brandon Rogers
12. Sanjaya Malakar

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Top 12 Performance: Brandon Rogers

Brandon has the unenviable position of starting off the show, and much to my (and I'm sure his own) disappointment, he's awful. I mean, it's like a trainwreck...he looks like he's wearing the pants my dad wears to work, he's got absolutely no charisma, his voice is swallowed up by the band, and then he cracks 1/3 of the way into the song. And to top it all of, he forgets his words.

Paula mentioned it must be nervewracking to go from a small studio into a big concert hall. Um, hasn't this guy toured with Christina Aguilera? Shouldn't he know from big concert halls? I mean, please.

Oh Brandon. Oh, Oh, Brandon. Not a promising start to the show.

Grade: D+


My Rankings, from best to worst: (Click on a contestant's name to read more detailed comments on their performance)
1. Lakisha Jones
2. Melinda Doolittle
3. Blake Lewis
4. Jordin Sparks
5. Chris Richardson
6. Phil Stacey
7. Chris Sligh
8. Stephanie Edwards
9. Gina Glocksen
10. Haley Scarnato
11. Brandon Rogers
12. Sanjaya Malakar

American Idol Top 12: What Order Will They Fall?


In what could best be described as an exercise in futility, I have decided to try and predict the order in which this year's Top 12 Idols will get voted off. As we all know, anything could happen at any point on this show, and there are a million reasons why a contestant could end up either leaving before their time or overstaying their welcome, so the chances of this list being relevant even a few weeks from now are pretty slim. After all, on the eve of the Top 12 performance in Season 5 could we have predicted that Bucky Covington would outlast Mandisa or that Chris Daughtry would get the boot before the final 3?

So, futile or not, here goes nothin'.

(Please note, this list is not in order of who I believe has the most talent or who I like the best, but rather it is the order I believe, at this very early point in the game, the contestants will get voted off)


12th Place: Haley Scarnato

See my post The "White Girl Spot": First to Go for my detailed logic, but I'm gonna have to go with history on this one and say Haley's gonna be the first casuality of AI6.

11th Place: Sanjaya Malakar

While not as blatant a pattern as the 12th place spot, it seems the second person sent home has historically been someone who probably shouldn't have made it to the Finals in the first place: Jim Verraros, Charles Grigsby, Matt Rogers, Mikalah Gordon, and Kevin Covais. Mr. Malakar will hopefully follow in their auspicious footsteps.

10th Place: Phil Stacey

Phil, to me, is a 'one-off'...he's almost cool and fun, and almost a really good singer, but not quite. Though I think he'll wear out his welcome and get sent back to his new baby by week 3, he'll be leavin' her once again to hit the road on tour this summer as part of the top 10.

9th Place: Brandon Rogers

Brandon could go earlier if he keeps up his snooze-inducing performances, but if he jives with the themes I can see him outlasting weird-beginning-of-songs Phil. Based on what we've seen so far, though, I gotta say I'm not expecting fireworks from Brandon during his time on the show.

8th Place: Stephanie Edwards

If it plays out as I've imagined 12 through 9 (and the chances of that are, oh, I don't know, slim-to-none), this is where I think Stephanie will have real difficulty siphoning votes from the other remaining girls.

7th Place: Jordin Sparks

Stephanie's saving grace will be if Jordin Sparks pulls a Lisa Tucker and shows her youth and vocal limitations too early (no, Lisa Tucker, it was not a good idea to sing Kelly Clarkson's "Because of You" in week 3) If she can keep on rockin' out like she did to "Heartbreaker" I think she could outlast Stephanie, although I can't imagine a scenario in which she finishes higher than 7th.

6th Place: Gina Glocksen

Gina has the distinct advantage of being different than every other girl in this competition, so she doesn't have to worry about vote-splitting and should easily survive the first several weeks. It will depend on how her vocals hold up and if she makes smart song choices, but finishing in the Carmen Rasmussen/Kimberly Caldwell range of #6 sounds about right.

5th Place: Chris Richardson

Will Blake and Chris R split the teenage girl vote? Possibly, but I'd bet there are so many teenage girls who watch this show that it won't even matter. If they do end up splitting the vote, however, I think Blake will likely have a broader range of fans by this point in the competition, simply due to the fact that he has more skills at his disposal. Chris, then, will have to settle for number 5.

4th Place: LaKisha Jones

On the surface it might seem odd to compare LaKisha to Tamyra Gray or Latoya London, but I believe LaKisha, like Tamyra and Latoya before her, will continue to inspire awe with her voice but find it difficult to really engage the audience with her personality. Her main female competition is obviously Melinda, who is incredibly likable and has provided the ultimate backstory (shy backup singer emerges into the spotlight). I'm thinking unless LaKisha can turn it up a notch in the personality department she may be looking at a fourth place finish.

3rd Place: Chris Sligh

This is the point in the list where I really start doubting myself, because as much as I like Chris Sligh now, do I really think he is going to finish #3? Ahead of LaKisha? I suppose I do, since there is his name up by 3rd place. I'm guessing halfway through the season Chris is going to become the love-him-or-hate-him character of the season, and his 'Fro Patrol will carry him a long way, though not quite the distance.

2nd Place: Melinda Doolittle

Winner of American Idol: Blake Lewis

Like I said, Melinda's got the backstory, and she's definitely got the voice, but when it comes down to the final 2 and she is standing next to Blake, the first contestant to bring an authentically hip, current feel to the show since Fantasia, who will American annoint its next Idol? At this moment I gotta go with Blake, who I'm guessing will have, by this point, dazzled the audience with his talent and versatility. Melinda, who is sure to be the most consistent performer in the competition (consistently great, at that), will have to settle for second place.

Or Sanjaya could win the whole thing. I mean, what the hell do I know?

Click to read Ten Best First Finals Performances

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Semifinal Performances: Jared and Brandon

JARED COTTER
Can I just say that I LOVE that they showed Jared missing a dunk as he says, "One day I realized I wasn't going to make the NBA." I mean, that is genius editing, people. Jared is cute, yeah fine I get it, but I am thoroughly unenthused by both his personality and his performance. Wearing white sneakers does not a pop star make, my friends. His pedestrian performance of Stevie Wonder's "If You Really Love Me" (I mean, Ryan Starr sang it better in Season 1) is kind of cringe-worthy. Not because he's missing notes, just because its so ordinary. (Props to a surprisingly lucid Paula for pointing out that Jared's performance is totally color-less) Is this the same show that turned out Chris Daughtry and Elliott Yamin last year?
Grade: C+

BRANDON ROGERS
Ah, Brandon shows some signs of life, revealing that he's a classical pianist (at least on what looks like the Casio keyboard I had in third grade) It makes me like him a little bit more. See, Sundance, this is what revealing something unknown about you can do. I'm not sure "Celebrate" was the best song choice, and as Randy said he did seem to have trouble with the timing toward the end, but at least he's got a bounce to his step and he's pushing himself more vocally than he has in the past couple of weeks. But still, for a cute guy with a nice voice and professional experience, I wish I was more excited about him. Rickey Smith from Season 2 and George Huff from Season 3 both had better voices and more personality, and yet neither made much of a dent in the competition. I'm afraid that will be Brandon's fate as well.
Grade: B